Day 10 saw only three witnesses on the stand: FBI Agent Brian Corcoran, FBI Special Agent Philip Christiana, and FBI Special Agent Kevin Swinden.
69. FBI Agent Brian Corcoran
Agent Corcoran, a bomb technician, testified the day before and was back on the stand in the morning, still under direct. Basically, this guy testified to a whole host of things found on Laurel Street in Watertown.
– The pressure cooker’s “blast seat”
– Locations of the pressure cooker, the lid, the locking mechanism
– A computer bag in which was found: a Samsung laptop, a cell phone with two batteries, a transmitter with an antenna (aka “modified piece of electronics”), foreign legal document with Tamerlan Tsarnaev’s name on it, Tamerlan’s 2006 high school diploma from Cambridge Rindge & Latin (also included were class schedules and attendance records), and a laser pointer.
– A messenger bag that contained a UMass pencil, Zippo lighter and an 8G thumb drive.
– a Jansport backpack
Let’s start with the “blast seat” on Laurel Street and Corcoran’s testimony about the pressure cooker. Andrew Kitzenberg of 62 Laurel Street took a photo of the blast seat as seen below on the left, the photo in the center was used as evidence by the prosecution during trial, and the last one is the area of the blast seat seen on Bing maps (No actual blast marks in the last photo).
Do I think the blast seat is particularly interesting? No. So let’s talk about where pieces of the pressure cooker landed. The pressure cooker itself exploded into the side of a Honda Civic. At the time, the vehicle was parked next to another car in a driveway and blocked in from behind by a police SUV. Take a look at the photos below. The fact that it seemed near impossible for the pressure cooker to plow into the side of the car at that angle was the only thing during the entire course of the trial that the defense not only argued, but went so far as to insinuate that someone planted it in the side of the car. I’m not disputing the odds of the cooker landing where it did, but this, this is the war Judy Clarke waged during the trial? I mean, come on. The least she could have done was haul in Bill Nye, the science guy, to talk about trajectories. But nah. She didn’t.
Even more interesting is where the pressure cooker lid came to rest. According to Agent Corcoran, authorities found the lid in the side yard at 53 Laurel Street in a hockey/soccer net. Yeah. I wish I was making that up. I’m not. Below, I’ve posted on the left a photo that was used during the trial that shows the net with the lid inside it, in the center is a photo of the front of 53 Laurel Street, and to the right is the earlier photo of the blast seat which shows the house next door and just to the east of 53 Laurel Street.
Here’s another look (the star is the bomb, the circle is the net):
Now I’m no expert but unless I missed Corcoran’s testimony about how the lid did a bank shot off what I can only assume is 49 Laurel Street, this is the most amazing flying lid I’ve ever seen. I mean, if the net opening was facing the west and the lid came from the east…well, you understand. However, before anyone starts calling up Dwight Schrute with their conspiracy theories, it is possible the police moved the net before taking evidence pictures like they did with the pencil on Henneberry’s boat or the stuff in the bedroom on Norfolk. I’m not sure when moving evidence before taking pictures used at trial became fashionable but, hey, maybe they didn’t. Which then leaves us back at square one: the magic
loogie lid. Or the bank shot.
Corcoran briefly touched on the computer bag found in the Honda Civic on Laurel Street and the “modified piece of electronics” or a transmitter with a dead man’s switch on it. But overall, not much was said about the transmitter which leaves us to wonder what the transmitter was for – or rather, to which bomb did it belong? Was it for either of the two bombs that were detonated on Boylston Street? Or both? Can one transmitter even detonate two bombs? Or how about the pressure cooker that exploded on Laurel Street? Or none of the above? We may never know. But what do we know? The government has never shown us anything that was used to set off the bombs on Bolyston Street, nor have they said they found anything. Disturbing? It should be. A cell phone was also found in the bag and journalists reported it as an AT&T or HTC cell phone. So between the Tsarnaevs’, how many cellphones have we seen so far in this trial?
1. 617-286-9151: The T-Mobile phone used at the Boston marathon. Also the phone used to call Viskhan Vakhabov before the April 18, 2013 carjacking and to call Tamerlan Tsarnaev after the carjacking. The account was created the day before the marathon bombings. It was found smashed behind a shed on Franklin St. in Watertown.
2. 857-247-5112: This phone number was seen on Jahar’s resume. The phone was also used to text Kadyrbayev on April 18th, 2013. It was found smashed behind a shed on Franklin St. with the 617-276-9151 phone.
3. Jahar had a phone that was turned off for lack of payment sometime around time of the bombings. One reporter said it was disconnected on April 17, 2013.
4. A Samsung cellphone was found in Jahar’s dorm room. This phone may or may not be the phone that was disconnected. (Special Agent Swindon testified about this phone later in the day).
1. 857-928-4634: T-Mobile. Phone used at the Boston marathon. Account created on 7/18/2012.
Now that we have that straightened out, whose phone was found at Laurel and Dexter? No idea. Spoiler alert: We’re never told. At this point, I can only assume it was Tamerlan’s. Outside of Corcoran’s testimony about property damage on Laurel Street, the only thing left worth talking about, at least for today, is that high school diploma found in the computer bag, am I right? I mean, as I’ve noted before, when those crazy kids were headed east (Edit: Not east into the ocean, I meant south to NY. Obviously.) to blow up New York City according to carjacking victim, Dun Meng, clearly they were going to need Tamerlan’s high school diploma. And class schedules. From seven years ago. Because that makes perfect sense. Said no one. Ever.
70. FBI Special Agent Philip Christiana
On April 19, 2013, prior to Jahar’s capture, Agent Christiana, a bomb technician who works out of the New Bedford, New Hampshire field office, responded to the apartment of Jahar’s friends, Dias Kadrybayev and Azamat Tazhayakov, at 69A Carriage Drive in New Bedford. Remember Jahar’s friends that were arrested? These are two of them.
Christiana’s testimony was fairly short. He testified that he was part of the hostage team that removed “three individuals” out of the apartment and then swept the apartment for, well, probably for just about anything. One of the neighbors on Carriage Drive appears to have been on friendly terms with Jahar and 1420 WSBM posted a quick interview with the guy who said that Jahar, Kadrybayev, Tazhayakov and a fourth friend, Robel Phillipos were all on the same cellular plan → HERE. For the indictment against Kadrybayev and Tazhayakov, you can find it on the justice.gov website → HERE. So what did Jahar’s friends do exactly? On April 18, 2013, after the FBI released photos of the “bombers,” Jahar’s friends went to his dorm room and removed his backpack which contained a handful of fireworks, Vaseline, a thumb drive and a homework assignment. They also removed his Sony VAIO laptop. After returning with Jahar’s things to their New Bedford apartment, Kadrybayev eventually put the backpack and its contents into the dumpster that evening.
Yeah, I got it. They thought they were throwing out incriminating evidence like a few fireworks, which, inevitably contained no where near enough powder to make even a little, itty, bitty, baby bomb, and the Vaseline that Jahar had mentioned was used in bombs during a previous conversation with his friends. I don’t know, did any FBI bomb technicians testify at trial that they found traces of Vaseline in any of the bombs? Oh, that’s right. No. And did Jahar’s friends remove his cell phone from his UMass dorm room? No. Did they take and dispose of Jahar’s white hat seen in the FBI photos? No. Did they throw out Jahar’s laptop? No. They left it in plain sight on their dining room table and Christiana testified authorities confiscated it the day he was dispatched to the apartment on April 19, 2013. Were Jahar’s friends really that naive or ignorant about what could be used as incriminating evidence against Jahar? Jahar’s friend, Stephen Silva, wasn’t. He chucked his own cellphone as soon as he realized the gravity of the situation.
Here’s what the news reported a week after the Feds allegedly took possession of Jahar’s laptop: According to ABC News, three law enforcement sources told them both Tamerlan and Jahar had spent time at the New Bedford apartment sometime after the bombings. Not only that, authorities were searching in a nearby landfill not for Jahar’s, but, rather, Tamerlan’s laptop. The article also claimed that Tamerlan’s cellphone was recovered from the New Bedford apartment. Huh? The only cellphone that Christiana testified to confiscating from the apartment was Kadrybayev’s iPhone 4S. Even weirder, during trial, @gailwaterhouse tweeted, “Inside the apt is a large gray couch, a TV on, end tables & an Apple computer can be seen.” Then she tweeted, “Behind the couch is a black dining table, 2 chairs. Another laptop on that table underneath a baseball hat.” So who owned the Apple computer? Even if it wasn’t Tamerlan’s or Jahar’s, why wouldn’t the Feds grab it? So…Jahar was still hiding in a boat, the Feds claimed they had no idea how many individuals were involved in the bombings at that point and they don’t take the other laptop?
Is ABC News and Gail Waterhouse smoking what Jahar was selling? No idea. US Dept. of Homeland Security Agent, James Wiroll, while on the stand during the Kadyrbayev trial, read from a federal report (I’m assuming an FBI interview with Kadyrbayev) that Kadyrbayev told authorities he had thrown away the backpack and the laptop. Now if you’re looking to maybe, say, skate from any or all federal charges, why would you admit to tossing the laptop if you didn’t toss the laptop? Yet, as of today, authorities say Kadyrbayev did not throw away the laptop. Christiana’s testimony reflected the same thing. I don’t have the Wiroll transcripts but you can read about his testimony HERE and HERE.
Lastly, a Superseding Indictment filed on August 29, 2013, charged both Kadyrbayev and Tazhayakov with, “agreeing to knowingly alter, destroy, conceal, and cover up tangible objects belonging to Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, namely a laptop computer…” Is taking a laptop and setting it on top of your dining room table in plain view altering, destroying, concealing or covering it up? I guess according to authorities it is. For other news sources that carried almost the same news story as ABC about the laptop and the landfill go to NBCNews → HERE (officials apparently told NBC the same thing) or the New York freakin’ Times who did an entire article on the missing laptop in the landfill six days after the laptop was allegedly found in the New Bedford apartment → HERE or a NYmag.com article which stated, “A law enforcement official tells the the New York Times that on Thursday investigators were combing through the Crapo HIll Landfill in New Bedford” because “‘they believe that the computer may have been thrown out.'” → HERE.
I mean, what?
71. FBI Special Agent Kevin Swinden
Agent Swinden has been with the Bureau for over eighteen years and currently works out of the Boston office in the cyber squad, which also includes the Computer Analysis Response Team. He is an expert in computer forensics and computer analysis recovery. And yes, I’m skipping over every bit of his testimony that would fall under Forensics 101. The bottom line when it came to the Boston bombing and digital evidence recovery and processing? The work load was insane and tons of people were called in to help with “terabytes of data.”
Agent Swinden was like Agent Corcoran in the sense he pretty much went over a laundry list of items only his testimony focused on electronic devices and the files on them. I’m going to make this pretty simple for you guys. I’m simply listing many of files found on each device that Agent Swinden examined.
I. JAHAR’S SONY VAIO LAPTOP
Full Name: Jahar
Last login: 4/17/13 at 8:30pm
Files: Over 4,000
Accounts: May include an account for “Bella Rizwan
Desktop Folders: “Al Makdisi”, “Nasheed”, “Papka”, “The Hereafter Series”, and “Ye”
“Allah the Prophet of Mercy and War!”
“Rasool Allah Inspiring Words of Truth”
“Jihad is the Way”
“Call for Jihad”
“Muslim has Supernatural Experience with Jesus”
“The Battle of Uhud Part 55”
At least two dozen Real Time Player files
“Join the Caravan”(last accessed 3/13)
“Complete Inspire”(created 1/21/12) including “Make a Bomb in the Kitchen of Your Mom”
“Jihad and the Effects of Intention”
“The Predator War” (Written by Jahar. Class assignment about drones)
578-page document in Cyrillic (Depicts a man on the front holding a handgun)
“Allah Selects the Martyrs” (A poster for a movie or video)
Files named “Imam Anwar Al Awlaki”
“The Hereafter Series”
“Gems and Jewels”
“Book of the End”
“The Slicing Sword”
Two photos of Jahar
Jahar and Stephen Silva at high school graduation
“The Best Islamic Song”
Other Nasheed (Islamic chant)
Anwar al-Awlaki lectures
II. COMPUTER IN NORFOLK HOME
User name: Umar
No full name listed.
This computer was used by many people.
email@example.com email: Accessed on 1/01/13. On this same day, there was a search for “Anwar Al Awlaki”
Last computer login: 3/21/13
“CompleteInspire.pdf (downloaded 12/26/1
Multiple Al-Awaki files
*The Islamic files seen on Jahar’s laptop were also seen on the home computer.
III. THUMB DRIVE TAKEN FROM JAHAR’S DORM ROOM AT UMASS DARTMOUTH
(Or from the NEW BEDFORD APARTMENT depending on the reporter you follow)
Picture of the March 2011Inspire cover story “The Tsunami of Change”
Image of Katherine Tsarnaev’s paycheck “earnings statement”
Pay stub from Donald Larking (@henrygrass)
IV. JAHAR’S PHONE FOUND IN THE DORM ROOM (the Samsung)
Image of Jahar (selfie) wearing earphones
17 pages of contacts in the phone including “Da Pope”
A paper by Dias Kadyrbayev entitled, “Definition and Examples of Manifest and Latent Function in Society”
100s of images and audio files: Chechen jihad, Jishad Nasheed, Jihad Nashee Chechen Mujahideen
*Again, many files were on multiple devices
V. TAMERLAN’S LAPTOP FOUND ON LAUREL STREET
It was taken to Russia from January thru July, 2012 (this is testimony from a different day)
Password: Allahu Akbar 1
TrueCrypt encryption software
Inspire magazine (installed on 12/21/11)
VI. SEAGATE HD HARD DRIVE ON COMPUTER FOUND IN COMPUTER BAG
“The Weapon of the Believer”
“Join the Caravan”
CompleteInspire.pdf (create on 12.27.12)
English assignment by someone named “Giovanni Norgil”
*All files on the external hard drive came from Tamerlan’s laptop*
VII. IPOD SHUFFLE AND IPOD NANO FOUND IN HONDA CIVIC ON LAUREL STREET
“The Man Who Went Jannah Without Praying” (on all four devices)
“The Best Nasheed in the World”
A Skillrex song. *gasp*
*A lot of the Islamic music on both the nano and shuffle seen on laptop and home computer
VIII. CD ROMS FROM THE HONDA CIVIC AND MERCEDES SUV
Audio of Anwar Al-Awlaki
IX. ORANGE PATRIOT BRAND THUMB DRIVE FOUND IN MESSENGER BAG ON LAUREL
Defense objected to discussing this thumb drive – relevancy
Two papers by Dias Kadyrbayev from Sociology 101
X. KINGSTON THUMB DRIVE FOUND IN BACKPACK IN LANDFILL IN NEW BEDFORD
The thumb drive had a lot of corrupted files that wouldn’t open.
Two files: “How to Treat Women” “Women’s Islamic Names”
“Join the Caravan” (again)
“Defense of Muslim Lands ”
“Dua Weapon of the Believer”
“ The Giant Man”
“Figh Made Easy ”
“Message of Believers ”
“Book of the End”
“ Allah’s Pleasure”
“ A Message to Every Youth” (by At-Tibyan Publications)
Katherine Tsarnaeva’s rental application
XI. iPHONES FOUND SMASHED BEHIND SHED ON FRANKLIN STREET
Authorities were only able to retrieve information from the SIM cards i.e. phone number, ownership. As pointed out earlier, one of these phones was used at the marathon, the other used on Jahar’s resume and to communicate with friends on April 18, 2013.
*More testimony about the Tsarnaev’s electronic devices continued on Day 11 and Day 16 of trial.